Week 10 Recap - Separation Saturday
On what College GameDay dubbed "Separation Saturday," we got seven ranked-versus-ranked matchups, a top-two team losing for the fifth consecutive week, and eight ranked teams going down on Saturday.
There was no shortage of great football, from the opening kickoff all the way through the late-night West Coast window. Some teams saw their playoff hopes disappear, while others made statements that they belong in the conversation and deserve to be taken seriously.
November 7th was circled on the calendar back in August as the best weekend of the season, and boy, did it deliver. With just three weeks remaining in the regular season, the playoff picture is getting more interesting by the minute.
Let's dive into everything that happened and what it means moving forward.
College football moves fast. Don’t miss a thing.
The College Football Newsletter brings you the biggest games, wildest upsets, top storylines, and plenty of opinions from across the country—all delivered straight to your inbox every week.
Subscribe and make The College Football Newsletter part of your weekly routine.
Notre Dame Finally Wins a Big Game
The No. 1 team in the country, Miami, traveled to South Bend, Indiana, to take on Notre Dame in a game that was extremely important for the Irish, but perhaps not quite as important for the Hurricanes.
Earlier in the week, it was announced that Miami star wide receiver Malachi Toney would undergo ankle surgery and miss the remainder of the regular season. This was a significant blow to the Hurricanes' offense, but with Darian Mensah and Mark Fletcher Jr. still in the backfield, you couldn't count Miami out. Notre Dame, on the other hand, was playing for its season. After losing to BYU last month, the Irish needed to win this game. Otherwise, they would finish 0-2 against their two best opponents for the second consecutive season.
That extra motivation helped the Irish get off the bus quickly and jump out to a 24-3 lead midway through the third quarter. It looked like the absence of Toney was really starting to affect Miami, while its defense was struggling to slow down the Irish. Notre Dame quarterback C.J. Carr threw three touchdown passes, one to Jordan Faison and two to Micah Gilbert, as the Irish were forced to punt just twice through the first two and a half quarters.
With their backs against the wall, Miami was forced to either do something or lie down and die. They chose to fight back as Darian Mensah finally led a touchdown drive to cut the deficit to 24-10. Miami's defense was now forced to step up, and it delivered, forcing back-to-back three-and-outs. The Hurricanes added another touchdown to make it 24-17, but on their attempt to tie the game, Mensah threw just his second interception of the season.
Notre Dame quickly turned that mistake into six points with a Nolan James Jr. touchdown run, pushing the lead back to 14 after the extra point. Miami answered quickly with another Mensah touchdown pass, and after Notre Dame kicker Spencer Porath badly missed a 53-yard field goal, the Hurricanes had another opportunity to tie the game.
Miami drove all the way to the Notre Dame 18-yard line and faced fourth-and-six. This was the defining moment of the game. Mensah looked for Elijah Lofton in the end zone, and it initially appeared that Lofton had made the catch and gotten both feet in bounds. However, Notre Dame defender Luke Talich got his hands in and broke up the pass, turning the ball over on downs.
Notre Dame managed to run most of the remaining clock off before punting the ball back to Miami with just one minute left and no timeouts. The Hurricanes' last-second drive came up short, and their desperation lateral play failed after just one pitch.
Notre Dame gets the win and proves that the Irish aren't just worthy of a playoff spot, but are legitimate contenders for a national championship.
Let's Talk About the Officiating
Now, let's talk about what some people are calling an officiating controversy. I want to be very clear about my position: I 100% think the officials got this call right.
Some people, and by some people I mean Miami fans and head coach Mario Cristobal, argue that Elijah Lofton caught that ball. I genuinely don't understand how anyone can come to that conclusion.
Lofton gets both feet in bounds and initially appears to have control of the football, but less than half a second later, the ball gets ripped away. NCAA Rule 2-4-3 outlines the requirements for a legal catch in college football:
- Firm Control: The player secures firm control of the live ball in flight with their hands or arms before it touches the ground.
- In-Bounds Contact: The player touches the ground in bounds with any part of their body, such as one foot.
- Act Common to the Game: The player maintains control long enough to perform an act common to the game, such as pitching or handing off the ball, advancing it, or warding off an opponent.
While Lofton appeared to satisfy the first two requirements, there is no way he maintained control of the ball long enough to satisfy the third. If you watch the replay and imagine that same play happening at midfield, it is ruled incomplete 100 times out of 100. There should be no question.
CBS rules analyst Gene Steratore explained that the rules in this situation are the same regardless of where the play happens. Just because the catch is in the end zone doesn't change the requirements. Unlike a play where a runner dives for the pylon and the ball breaks the plane of the goal line, Lofton was still required to maintain control through the catch.
There is simply no question in my mind that this wasn't a catch. Anyone arguing otherwise should take a deep look at what they actually believe constitutes a completed pass. Should a player be able to catch the ball in the end zone, immediately drop it, and have it count as a touchdown? Think about how ridiculous that sounds.
Notre Dame dominated this game, and despite Miami's late comeback attempt, the Irish held strong and deserved this victory. The Hurricanes had their opportunity to steal one late, but Notre Dame's defense made the play when it mattered most.
The Holy War
BYU and Utah faced off in the 104th edition of the Holy War, marking the first time the two teams have met as Top 10-ranked opponents. The game kicked off at 10:00 a.m. local time in Salt Lake City, and BYU looked like it was still waking up. Utah and Devon Dampier scored on their first three plays, forced a BYU punt, and found the end zone just four plays later. It was 14-0 less than five minutes into the game, and it looked like things were about to get ugly for the Cougars.
BYU's defense eventually settled in. After allowing two field goals and forcing a pair of punts, Bear Bachmeier blew the top off the Utah defense with a deep ball to freshman Legend Galsker for a 75-yard touchdown, bringing the Cougars within one score. A forced fumble gave BYU the ball back in excellent field position, and eight plays later, LJ Martin, playing in his first game after missing four weeks with an ankle injury, punched it into the end zone. Utah would fumble again inside its own 20-yard line, setting up BYU with an opportunity to deliver what could have been an early knockout punch. However, Bachmeier sailed a pass intended for Kyler Kasper, and the Utes escaped the first half trailing by just six.
BYU dominated the final 25 minutes of the first half and was set to receive the second-half kickoff. After driving into Utah territory, Bachmeier made his second mistake of the game when a tipped pass was intercepted by the Utes. Despite an insane fourth-down call by Utah, which resulted in wide receiver Creed Whittemore throwing a 29-yard pass to Devon Dampier on fourth-and-one, the Utes eventually had to settle for a 29-yard field goal attempt. Kicker Dillon Curtis pushed it wide right, keeping BYU in front.
BYU's defense was showing signs of stress, but it continued to hold. That is, until the next time it stepped onto the field.
Dampier sliced and diced his way through the Cougars' defense as Utah found the end zone to take a 28-20 lead. That score would ultimately hold as the final. BYU had an opportunity to answer, driving 65 yards before facing third-and-goal from the two-yard line. Bachmeier spotted a wide-open Kyler Kasper in the end zone but failed to account for Utah linebacker Trey Reynolds, who stepped in front of the pass for an interception. It's a play that could have easily turned into a touchdown with a little more air under the ball.
BYU would force another punt, but with no timeouts and questionable play calling, the Cougars were forced to attempt a Hail Mary with just ten seconds remaining. Once again, Kasper appeared to have an opportunity in the end zone, but Utah defensive back Nate Ritchie recovered and stepped in front of the throw, giving Bachmeier his fourth interception of the game.
Utah Was the Better Team
I'll give Utah credit where it's due: the Utes were the better team. They played more disciplined football, and when BYU erased their 14-0 lead, they didn't panic or start forcing things. BYU, on the other hand, came out flat and put itself in an early hole.
I will give the Cougars credit for not panicking after that disastrous start. They made adjustments and responded to what Utah was doing. On the opening drives, BYU's defense looked like it was trying to make a play rather than simply doing its job. Players were biting on nearly every fake and abandoning their assignments. That led to Utah's two quick touchdowns. After that, however, the defense settled down and played much better.
The BYU offense found its rhythm in the first half, exploiting Utah's man coverage and finding opportunities downfield. But that success quickly disappeared after halftime. Utah brought more pressure in the second half, and BYU's play calling failed to adjust. The Utes continued playing man coverage on the outside, but the Cougars couldn't find ways to get the ball into the hands of their speedy receivers.
BYU's Second-Half Problem
What really frustrated me was the defense. At the first sign of Utah moving the ball again, BYU reverted to its undisciplined tendencies. Players were biting on every fake, failing to contain Dampier, and Isaiah Glasker wasn't wrapping up on a tackle because he wanted to deliver a highlight-reel hit instead.
This is now the second consecutive game in which BYU dominated the end of the first half, only to completely disappear after the break. The Cougars managed just 110 total yards in the second half, scored zero points, and committed three turnovers.
BYU entered the red zone five times and found the end zone just once. Add their 11 penalties, majority of them being procedural, and you can't expect to be a playoff team while putting up those kinds of numbers. And there isn't just one person to blame. Everything from the play calling to the execution was bad in the second half. If BYU is truly serious about being a playoff contender, everything needs to be evaluated.
What's Next for Utah?
Utah didn't dominate BYU the way it dominated Cincinnati, but the Utes proved they are one of the most dangerous teams in the country. The secondary is still a concern, as BYU was able to exploit it throughout the first half. A more dynamic and explosive offense could give Utah some problems down the road.
The Utes also struggled to establish the running game during the first 30 minutes, another potential concern as the season progresses. But for now, Utah continues to pass its tests.
Next week's trip to Arizona is arguably the Utes' final true test of the regular season. With the Holy War victory in hand, a trip to Arlington for the Big 12 Championship Game now looks almost certain.
Alabama Defends the Committee
Most people were upset with the No. 5 ranking the College Football Playoff selection committee gave Alabama on Tuesday. But the Crimson Tide backed up that ranking on Saturday afternoon, taking down LSU in Baton Rouge.
To say Alabama dominated this game would be a stretch. LSU outgained the Tide 457-285, recorded 14 more first downs, and held the ball for an additional five and a half minutes. However, none of that mattered when it came time to put points on the board.
The game got off to a slow start, with Alabama taking a 10-3 lead into halftime thanks to a Ryan Coleman-Williams touchdown. LSU, meanwhile, missed a field goal, turned the ball over on downs inside Alabama's 10-yard line, and watched Sam Leavitt throw an interception deep in Alabama territory just before halftime.
The deficit didn't scare the Tigers, as they came out of the locker room and kicked a field goal before scoring a touchdown to take their first lead of the afternoon, 13-10, with 2:44 remaining in the third quarter. Unfortunately for LSU, that's where the good times would end.
Alabama responded by going 75 yards in just five plays to retake the lead, 17-13. The Tide then forced another LSU turnover on downs before making the Tigers punt on their next possession. Ryan Coleman-Williams set up Alabama's next touchdown with an excellent punt return, and the Tide found the end zone on the very next play. LSU would turn the ball over on downs once again, and Alabama delivered the knockout punch three plays later to put the game away, 31-13.
Despite Sam Leavitt throwing for nearly 400 yards, LSU's inability to finish drives and repeated failures on fourth down ultimately cost the Tigers a chance to win. Alabama quarterback Keelon Russell played exceptionally well considering he battled ankle problems throughout the game. His three passing touchdowns and 25 rushing yards certainly didn't suggest he was playing through an injury.
LSU finished 0-for-4 on fourth-down attempts, and Lane Kiffin now falls to 0-6 against Alabama as a head coach. With games against Texas and Tennessee still remaining on the schedule, the Tigers' playoff hopes are all but gone. A three-loss team could still make the playoff, but I don't see LSU being that team. Their only ranked victories have come against Texas A&M and Mississippi State, two teams that have combined for just one conference win since facing the Tigers.
Meanwhile, Alabama sits at 7-2 and looks more than capable of finishing the regular season 10-2, potentially earning another shot at Georgia in the SEC Championship Game. Winning a game in which they were significantly outgained is something we haven't seen much from this Kalen DeBoer-led team, but several players stepped up when they needed to.
The loss to Tennessee remains a pretty ugly blemish on Alabama's résumé, but it's 2026, and seemingly every team has a bad loss on its record. The difference is that Alabama still has an opportunity to make a run at the SEC title and the College Football Playoff. After Saturday, the committee's No. 5 ranking doesn't look quite as controversial.
Ohio State is Done, are the Ducks?
The Ohio State Buckeyes are officially eliminated from the College Football Playoff. It's the first time they will miss the 12-team playoff, and the earliest they've ever been eliminated from playoff contention since the playoff began in 2014. It's also the first time since 2011 that Ohio State has lost three games in a season, and things might still get worse.
Ever since quarterback Julian Sayin went down with an injury, it's been a nightmare in Columbus. Losing to USC on the road was the first domino to fall, but coming home and getting dominated by Oregon was the biggest one. The Buckeyes got off to a hot start, leading 14-0 after the first quarter, but everything fell apart after that.
Oregon faked a punt, scored a touchdown, intercepted Luke Fahey, and scored another touchdown in a matter of two minutes. Just like that, a 14-3 deficit turned into a 17-14 lead for the Ducks. They never looked back, piling on three more touchdowns to open up a 38-14 advantage. Two late garbage-time touchdowns made the final score look a little more respectable, but a 41-28 loss at home to a 5-3 Oregon team is certainly not what Ohio State had in mind.
Honestly, I don't know what the problem is. Sayin being hurt doesn't explain why Ohio State's defense gave up 41 points to an Oregon offense led by Dylan Raiola. Once again, the Buckeyes committed seven penalties and looked undisciplined for much of the night.
And while Jeremiah Smith finished with seven catches, 133 yards, and a touchdown, there's no excuse for Ohio State going the entire second and third quarters without even targeting him. He's the best player on the field. If Fahey can't get him the ball, find another way to get it into his hands. At this point, Smith should be taking snaps himself.
Ryan Day needs to be at the forefront of the criticism. It seems like Sayin's injury derailed the entire program, and that's a pretty damning indictment of the coaching staff. If I'm Smith, or even Sayin, why would I want to play another down this season? Smith already has the records, and the one thing he was chasing — the Heisman Trophy — is likely slipping away because the program doesn't have a competent backup quarterback. Sayin has to be sitting there wondering whether it's worth rushing back from an injury just to play in the Cheez-It Citrus Bowl.
Is Oregon Done?
Meanwhile, is Oregon actually done? The Ducks have losses to Oklahoma State, UCLA, and Illinois, with the Illinois loss looking like the dagger at the time. We know Dante Moore isn't coming back this season, but wins over USC and Ohio State — both on the road — are nothing to sneeze at.
Oregon still has to win out against Michigan, Michigan State, and Washington. All three have plenty of problems of their own, so that's certainly possible. But even if the Ducks take care of business, they'll likely need Indiana to lose another game and then have to win the tiebreaker to reach the Big Ten Championship Game.
It's a long shot, no doubt. But if this season has taught us anything, it's that counting teams out too early is probably a mistake.
SEC Race Shakes Out
Georgia Dominates
Georgia and Kirby Smart slayed any remaining demons that might have been lingering when it comes to Ole Miss, heading into Oxford and straight-up whipping the Rebels 42-7.
The game was essentially over by halftime, with Georgia leading 28-0. Ole Miss didn't find the end zone until the fourth quarter, and even then, it was far too little, far too late. Georgia's defense was stellar, allowing the Rebels to reach the red zone just once and rack up only 252 total yards. Meanwhile, the Georgia offense was clicking on all cylinders, piling up nearly 500 yards. The Bulldogs also forced two turnovers and ultimately dominated every facet of the game.
Georgia proved it is the best team in the SEC, and I think it made a pretty convincing case that it's the best team in the country, too. If that's the case, the road to the National Championship once again runs through Athens.
The Bulldogs now sit alone atop the SEC standings, and with only Missouri and South Carolina left on the schedule, a trip to Atlanta seems almost inevitable. Even if they stumble once along the way, Georgia is firmly in the driver's seat.
Tennessee Rolls
The Volunteers took the committee's disrespect personally and proved to the nation that they deserve to be ranked higher than No. 13 — and probably higher than Alabama, too.
While Kentucky was able to hang with Alabama for a half, Tennessee dominated the Wildcats from start to finish, taking down the No. 6 team in the country 34-6. The Vols' defense forced three turnovers while the offense pounded the rock all afternoon. DeSean Bishop finished with 109 yards and two touchdowns, Daune Morris added 85 yards and another score, and Faizon Brandon chipped in 29 more yards on the ground.
Tennessee now sits at 4-2 in conference play and holds the tiebreaker over the other two-loss teams, Kentucky and Alabama. The Vols' three-point losses to Texas and South Carolina continue to look better and better as both teams keep winning.
It will be difficult for Tennessee to reach the SEC Championship Game, but that might not be the worst thing in the world. Think back to 2024, when the Vols missed the conference title game but still made the College Football Playoff. If Tennessee can beat the Tigers — who will be playing the third game of a brutal stretch against Alabama, Texas, and Tennessee — the Vols should be in great position to secure another playoff berth.
Meanwhile, Kentucky's margin for error is gone. The Wildcats now have to win out against Florida, Missouri, and Louisville to keep their hopes of a first-ever College Football Playoff appearance alive.
Texas Closes Strong
It wasn't an easy road game for Texas, but the Longhorns proved they were the more complete team against Missouri. The Tigers have been playing well, especially at home, and this one was a back-and-forth battle for the first three quarters. With the score tied 20-20 heading into the fourth, Texas's defense buckled down and ultimately made the difference.
In the final quarter, the Longhorns allowed just 32 total yards and forced Missouri to punt three times. After Texas scored to take a 27-20 lead, Graceson Littleton forced a fumble that easily could have been returned for a touchdown. Instead, Littleton wisely slid down to keep the clock running, and Texas turned the possession into another touchdown just three plays later.
Much like it did in this game, Texas will likely need to lean on its defense down the stretch if it wants to finish the season strong. Next Saturday's matchup at LSU will be a chance to prove to the country that the Longhorns are truly ready for the playoff. Win that game, and they should be able to start booking their ticket to the 12-team bracket.
I'm not going to pretend to know whether Texas can win the two-loss tiebreaker and reach Atlanta for a shot at avenging its SEC Championship Game loss to Georgia two years ago. But here's something that deserves attention: Saturday marked Texas's fourth win over a ranked opponent this season. Oregon and Georgia are the only other teams in the country with even three.
That's one heck of a résumé.
Game of the Week: Texas Tech 53 West Virginia 48
With 68 combined points and 892 combined yards in the first half, it looked like West Virginia and Texas Tech were headed for a race to see who could score 100 first. West Virginia scored on five of its seven possessions, while Texas Tech found the end zone on six of its seven possessions. I had this game on the quad box right next to Michigan versus Michigan State, and boy, was it a contrast!
There were five touchdowns of more than 30 yards in this game, and while the scoring slowed down in the second half, the drama certainly didn't. Whether both offenses were exhausted from their first-half onslaught or the defenses finally made some adjustments, West Virginia forced four consecutive Texas Tech punts to open the second half.
During the Red Raiders' scoring drought, West Virginia and Michael Hawkins Jr. kept the offense rolling, scoring three touchdowns to turn a 41-27 deficit into a 48-41 lead.
Unfortunately for the Mountaineers, that's where their offense would stall. Over the remainder of the fourth quarter, Tommy Castellanos led Texas Tech to a field goal and a touchdown, giving the Red Raiders a three-point advantage with just under three minutes remaining.
West Virginia couldn't get anything going on its next possession. Despite stopping Castellanos on fourth down with 1:30 remaining, the Mountaineers' hopes for a miraculous comeback came to an end when Michael Hawkins Jr. lost his balance in the end zone on the first play of their ensuing drive and was sacked for a safety.
In total, this game produced 101 points, 1,220 yards, 13 touchdowns, and plenty of excitement for the 60,000 fans in attendance. Texas Tech pulled out the victory and still controls its own destiny in the Big 12, while West Virginia continues to show signs of rebuilding what WVU football means under Rich Rodriguez.
With games against Houston and Utah still remaining, West Virginia has another opportunity to play spoiler and make life difficult for the Big 12's playoff hopefuls.
Player of the Week
Nate Sheppard (Duke): 18 CAR, 217 YDS, 3 TD
Another outstanding performance from Duke running back Nate Shepard this week as the Blue Devils took down in-state rival NC State for the fourth consecutive time. Shepard averaged an incredible 12.1 yards per carry and scored a touchdown on roughly every six touches. His longest run of the afternoon was a 69-yard touchdown that got the game started.
Shepard now has eight touchdowns over his last two games and 17 on the season. Only Michael Hawkins Jr., Cade Hellums, and Jackson Gutierrez have more, with Hawkins sitting at 19 and the other two at 18. All three are quarterbacks, and two play for service academies.
Shepard would need to average more than seven touchdowns per game over Duke's final three contests to break Barry Sanders' record for most touchdowns in a single season. While that record is likely out of reach, Shepard has been far and away the most dominant running back in college football this season.
Similar to the records for passing yards and passing touchdowns, I don't think anyone will come particularly close to Sanders' record under the current college clock rules, let alone the 33 touchdowns Montee Ball recorded in 2011 or the 32 and 28 Bryson Dally and Ashton Jeanty recorded in 2024.
Regardless, keep an eye on Shepard over the final few weeks of the season. Duke takes on Miami next Saturday, and the Blue Devils could have an opportunity to shake things up in the ACC. If Shepard keeps running like this, the Hurricanes could have their hands full.
In Case You Missed it
Florida is Swamped
The Gators were ranked in this past weeks CFP Rankings despite having three losses. Well they added another to that tally Saturday losing to Oklahoma. The Gators now fall to 3-4 in SEC play after allowing the Sooners to score 23 points.
Friday Night in Tucson
While most people were asleep across the country, Arizona was trying to keep their season alive. Down 28-20 with with two minutes remaining...it looked bleak. Until...
The ending of the TCU-Arizona game late last night was absolutely incredible ⚡️ pic.twitter.com/DN0WP2xL8c
— CFB Kings (@CFBKings) November 7, 2026
Another Kick Six?
I've talked about Duke and Nate Sheppard, but there was yet another kick six in this game.
KICK SIX FOR DUKE WOW
— CFP (@CFBPlayoff) November 7, 2026
📺 The CW x @ACCFootball pic.twitter.com/NA0n3DnT98
Florida State Fake
The Seminoles lined up to tie the game before half. Interim coach Rick Stockstill had other thoughts and would ultimately win his debut.
"I agree with the decision to kick here..."
— Jomboy Media (@JomboyMedia) November 7, 2026
Florida State pulls off a perfectly executed fake field goal pic.twitter.com/KRPGjwsN3v
Michigan State Spoils
Michigan fans though their season couldn't get any worse under Kyle Whittingham. Then the school they refer to as "little brother" came to town and held them scoreless for the first 48:25. Despite scoring late, the Spartans till prevailed and took home the Paul Bunyan trophy.
Pat Fitzgerald held Paul Bunyan, asking his Michigan State team after beating Michigan, “Whose state?”
— Brad Galli (@BradGalli) November 8, 2026
“Our state!” they chanted back. pic.twitter.com/ttEhBpIEAM
Michigan now falls to 5-4 on the year and with games left against Oregon, UCLA, and Ohio State, they have a real danger of missing a bowl game. In a last ditch effort to appease the Michigan faithful and maybe keep his job past this season, Whittingham fired OC Jason Beck Sunday afternoon.
Mid Week MACtion
Tuesday and Wednesday MAC games are back for the rest of the regular season as we were treated to outstanding mid week football. Toledo and Ohio survived as big favorites while UMass and Buffalo won in overtime and Central Michigan beat Eastern Michigan at Ford Field.
Heisman Predictions
This is normally where I talk about the rankings, but with the first College Football Playoff rankings not coming out until tomorrow, keep an eye on social media for my reaction.
Instead, I want to take a look at the ever-changing Heisman favorites as we head into the final stretch of the season.
According to FanDuel (no free ads), the Heisman favorites as of November 8 are:
- CJ Carr: +150
- Darian Mensah: +320
- Jeremiah Smith: +320
- Devon Dampier: +1400
- Drew Mestemaker: +1700
I think this is going to be a year where nobody truly takes control of the race. Carr played well against Miami but struggled against BYU. The lack of tougher competition on Notre Dame's schedule also makes it difficult for me to justify him as the clear favorite.
The player I'm really keeping an eye on is Devon Dampier, who currently has the fourth-best odds. He single-handedly willed Utah to a win over BYU and is putting up numbers that rival Carr's. Dampier has thrown for 2,053 yards and 20 touchdowns while adding another 480 yards and seven touchdowns on the ground. Carr, meanwhile, has 2,168 passing yards and 21 touchdowns, but just 89 rushing yards.
Dampier does have seven interceptions compared to Carr's one, which is certainly worth considering. But when you look at the overall production and what each player means to his team, I think Dampier deserves to be much higher in this race.
This is one of those years when I hate that the Heisman is strictly a regular-season award. I would love to see these two quarterbacks go head-to-head in the playoff and give the trophy to whoever performs better on the biggest stage. Unfortunately, that's not how it works.
With Malachi Toney out for the rest of the season, Oregon State struggling to win games, and Ohio State dealing with its quarterback issues, I think Toney, Legree, and Smith are all falling out of contention. LaNorris Sellers still has an outside shot if he continues playing the way he has over the last four games, but an ankle injury could derail that. South Carolina would also likely need to pull off a win over Georgia for Sellers to have a realistic chance.
Who knows how the voters will ultimately decide? My guess is that Dampier will make the trip to New York, and to me, he's the player on this list who carries his team more than anyone else. If the Heisman is supposed to go to the most outstanding player in college football, that's a pretty good place to start
The CFB Truth Podcast
I am happy to announce that I have joined a podcast! If the weekly newsletter and social media isn't enough for you, you can now tune in as we talk more about college football and The CFB Truth Index. Tune in Tuesdays and Fridays where ever you listen to your podcasts!
Will's Corner
Washington State Bye
For the first time since September 19th, I didn't have to watch WSU lose. The Cougs get to host Colorado State next weekend in Pullman. The Rams only have one Pac-12 win, and this seems to be the last chance for Wazzu to pick up a second win, fingers crossed as they kick off at 7:30 pm PT.
BYU 20, Utah 28
While most of my commentary is already listed above, the result of this game is still extremely frustrating. Watching undisciplined football is probably the worst way to watch your team. Defensive assignments being ignored, pre-snap mistakes, and procedural penalties are all things that are completely avoidable. BYU straight-up peed down its leg in the second half.
Zero points and three turnovers tell me one of two things: either the Cougars thought they had the game won at halftime, or the lights were simply too bright. As terrible as it is to say, that's just BYU football.
Over the last three years, BYU has had the talent to compete with the best teams in the country, but it continually finds ways to lose games and knock itself out of the playoff conversation. This game felt like another example of the same problem.
The Cougars finish the regular season against Baylor, Kansas, and Cincinnati. They still have a path to Arlington, but they're going to need plenty of help to get another shot at Utah in the Big 12 Championship Game. The opportunity is still there, but BYU has to prove it can get out of its own way first.
Tennessee 34, Kentucky 6
Tennessee straight-up bullied Kentucky. The Wildcats have won just once in Knoxville since 1985, and the Volunteers lead the all-time series 87-26-9. Tennessee didn't care how good Will Stein and Kentucky have looked this year. The Vols reminded the Wildcats who their daddy is.
Tennessee got off to a slow start offensively but eventually found its rhythm by leaning on the ground game. The defense, meanwhile, was outstanding. Kentucky had averaged 33.5 points over its previous six games, and the only time it failed to score more than 30 was against a great Oklahoma defense. Tennessee made the Wildcats look downright pedestrian. Kenny Minchey couldn't get anything going all night.
If this defense continues to show up like this, it's going to be awfully difficult for anyone to beat the Vols.
The trip to Texas A&M this Saturday shouldn't be overlooked, no matter how bad the Aggies have looked. But the home matchup against LSU is shaping up to be the final pivotal test in Tennessee's quest for another playoff appearance.
Survivor Pool Update
This week brought three more casualties to the remaining contestants.
Paul S. picked Arkansas State as they hosted UL Monroe, but the Warhawks had other plans and sent Paul packing in Week 10.
Matt B. got bit by the auto-pick bug as Coastal Carolina fell at home to Old Dominion. Unfortunately, the auto-pick wasn't quite the safety net he needed.
And Joe W. picked Michigan in what looked like a sure win in the Battle for Paul Bunyan. Unfortunately, that wasn't the case, as Michigan State knocked off its rival and sent Joe packing.
With just three weeks left in the regular season, 14 contestants remain! Remember to make your picks and keep your survival hopes alive for a chance to win a gameday experience next season.
Games to Watch Week 11
- 15. USC @ 6. Indiana – Nov 14, 3:30 PM ET (CBS) - USC's season hangs in the balance on if the can defeat the defending champions.
- 8. Texas @ 24. LSU– Nov 14, 7:30 PM ET (ABC) - Can Texas keep their streak of beating ranked teams alive, or will LSU start a rally when it's probably too late.
- 2. Utah @ 22. Arizona – Nov 14, 7:30 PM ET (FOX) - Can the Utes continue their Big 12 dominance or will Arizona get them in a classic let down spot.
- 10. Texas Tech @ Oklahoma State – Nov 14, 9:30 PM ET (ESPN) - A gamer circled for a while now, what seems to be certainly a shootout, who can score enough points to win?
Thank you for reading! It truly means a lot to me that you take the time to read this every week. If you enjoy the newsletter, please share it with your friends and family who love college football. Every new reader helps this thing grow, and I can't thank you enough! Don't forget to follow on socials!