Week 11 Recap - Order is Restored?

Share
Week 11 Recap - Order is Restored?

For the first time in five weeks, the streak of weekends featuring a top-two team going down has officially come to an end. Even crazier, every top-10 team in the country won for the first time since Week 1. Only four ranked teams fell to unranked opponents, and in every ranked-versus-ranked matchup, the higher-ranked team came out on top.

Has order finally been restored in the college football world? Are we done with the ridiculous upsets? Is the playoff picture actually starting to make sense?

Probably not. This is college football, after all.

Still, Saturday gave us something we haven't had much of lately: some clarity. Conference championship races are beginning to take shape, and the playoff picture is looking a whole lot clearer than it did just a week ago.

But don't mistake a quieter Saturday for a boring one. Some teams cemented themselves as legitimate contenders, while others watched their playoff hopes walk out the door. Let's get into who made a statement and who exited stage left during the second weekend of November.


College football moves fast. Don’t miss a thing.

The College Football Newsletter brings you the biggest games, wildest upsets, top storylines, and plenty of opinions from across the country—all delivered straight to your inbox every week.

Subscribe and make The College Football Newsletter part of your weekly routine.


Texas Earns Another Ranked Win

There are plenty of ways to win a football game, and then there is whatever Texas decided to do Saturday night in Baton Rouge.

The No. 6 Longhorns marched into Death Valley to take on No. 21 LSU, and despite what can only be described as a frustrating night for Arch Manning, Texas found a way to escape with a 22-21 victory. Manning threw three interceptions, struggled to get much going through the air, and looked far from the quarterback Texas needs him to be if they want to make a deep playoff run.

But here's the thing: it didn't matter.

Texas' defense came up with three interceptions of its own, including a historic performance from Jelani McDonald, who picked off Sam Leavitt three times. The Longhorns also held LSU scoreless in the fourth quarter, giving their offense a chance to steal one late.

And steal one they did.

Trailing 21-16 with just over two minutes remaining, Manning led Texas on a 12-play, 58-yard drive that ended with a four-yard touchdown pass to Raleek Brown with just three seconds left on the clock. After a night of mistakes, Manning delivered when it mattered most.

It was far from pretty, but Texas won't care. A road win against a ranked SEC opponent, in one of the toughest environments in college football, is a road win. And this one was especially important for the Longhorns' playoff resume.

Texas now has five victories over teams ranked in the latest CFP Top 25, the most in the country. They also picked up their first win in Death Valley since 1952.

Texas Is Still Standing

Two back-to-back three-point losses to unranked opponents, Oklahoma and Florida, are all that stand between Texas and an undefeated record. And yet, here we are in the middle of November, and the Longhorns are still sitting in the driver's seat for a playoff spot.

Sure, four of their five ranked wins have come by a single score. But who cares? Texas was always viewed as the team with arguably the toughest schedule in the country. When they dropped those two games, the critics were quick to point out that there was no way they would survive the rest of their schedule without taking another loss. Well, here we are.

After Saturday's win in Baton Rouge, Texas is now 5-0 against teams ranked in the latest CFP Top 25. No other team in the country has more than four wins against ranked opponents. That's not a fluke, and that's not something you can ignore when comparing playoff resumes.

Now, just two games against two of the SEC's bottom-tier teams stand between the Longhorns and a 10-2 regular season. Even more interesting is the SEC Championship picture. If Alabama, Texas, and Tennessee all finish 7-2 in conference play, Alabama appears to have the inside track to face Georgia in Atlanta. That might actually be the best-case scenario for Texas. Instead of having to play in the conference championship, the Longhorns could get an extra week to rest, recover, and prepare for their first-round playoff matchup.

$145 Million for This?

Meanwhile, LSU now sits at 6-4, and I'm not sure this is what the Tigers had in mind when they decided to make a coaching change.

LSU spent $54 million to move on from Brian Kelly, then turned around and hired Lane Kiffin on a seven-year, $91 million contract. All that money, all that hype, and all that offseason excitement just for the Tigers to find themselves in nearly the exact same position they were trying to escape.

LSU has been favored in all 10 games they've played this season, yet they have just six wins to show for it. Their only two wins over ranked opponents came against Texas A&M and Mississippi State, who have combined for just three conference wins. Every major test Kiffin was brought to Baton Rouge to win has ended in a loss.

The Tigers get another shot next week when they travel to Tennessee, but at this point, what is there left to play for? Their playoff hopes are gone, and what was supposed to be a championship-caliber season is quickly turning into a massive disappointment.

The best thing Kiffin can do now is turn his attention toward next season. More specifically, finding a quarterback who can actually take care of the football. Sam Leavitt threw three interceptions against Texas, and while Arch Manning certainly wasn't much better on the other sideline, the difference was that Texas found a way to win despite its quarterback.

Kiffin was brought in to win the big games, compete for championships, and get LSU back into the national spotlight. Instead, he's sitting at 6-4 with another season slipping away.


Indiana Gets Their Ranked Win

The Hoosiers Finally Get One

After weeks of struggling to put together a complete performance, Indiana finally has the ranked win it has been looking for. The No. 6 Hoosiers welcomed No. 15 USC to Bloomington and sent the Trojans home with a 27-13 loss.

Indiana has only lost to Ohio State and after falling five spots in the latest CFP rankings, despite having a bye last week, it left plenty of questions about whether this team was actually a playoff contender. Saturday was an opportunity to answer those questions, and they did just that.

But perhaps the biggest surprise of the afternoon was who was under center for the Hoosiers. With Josh Hoover dealing with a year of stuggles, sixth-year quarterback Grant Wilson got the start, and he made the most of it. In his first career Big Ten start, Wilson threw for 305 yards and two touchdowns, completing 17 of 27 passes. Not a bad afternoon for a guy who hasn't started a game since 2024 at Old Dominion.

Wilson connected with Brock Schott for an early touchdown, then delivered the biggest play of the game late in the fourth quarter. After Indiana's defense intercepted USC quarterback Jayden Maiava for the third time, Wilson found Charlie Becker for a 42-yard touchdown to put the game away.

Indiana's defense deserves plenty of credit, too. They forced three interceptions, held USC scoreless in the fourth quarter, and came up with the stops when the game was on the line.

The Hoosiers are now 9-1, and while they still have some work to do, this was exactly the type of win they needed heading into the final stretch of the season.

USC's Playoff Hopes Go Down the Drain

Meanwhile, USC's playoff hopes are gone.

The Trojans came into Bloomington knowing what was at stake. A win would keep their playoff hopes alive and give them a chance to make a run at the Big Ten Championship. Instead, they leave Indiana with their third loss of the season and a whole lot of questions.

USC actually had its opportunities. They outgained Indiana through the air, Jayden Maiava threw for 311 yards, and they managed to tie the game at 13 late in the third quarter. But the offense completely disappeared when it mattered most.

Maiava threw three interceptions, including two in the fourth quarter. One of those came inside Indiana's 10-yard line with the Trojans trailing by just seven. That's the kind of mistake you simply cannot make when your season is on the line.

USC also went just 1-for-5 in the red zone, leaving points on the field throughout the afternoon. They were given opportunities to take control of the game, and they failed to capitalize on just about every one of them.

Lincoln Riley was brought to Los Angeles to get USC back into national championship contention. Yet another season is slipping away, and the Trojans are once again left wondering what could have been.

At 7-3, their playoff hopes are gone. Indiana, on the other hand, just picked up the win it needed to remind everyone that the defending national champions aren't going anywhere.


Other Statements Made

Wake Forest

Despite being 8-1, with their only loss coming against Miami, the Wake Forest Demon Deacons still weren't being viewed as a legitimate playoff contender. Sure, they had beaten a lot of teams, and beaten them by a lot of points, but the argument was that they were beating up on teams that couldn't defend themselves and hadn't actually played anybody.

That changed this week when Wake Forest traveled to Dallas to take on SMU. The Mustangs had lost a head-scratcher to Syracuse, knocking them out of the Top 25, but at 7-2, they were still a respectable team. In fact, they were even favored by 2.5 points heading into this game.

The Demon Deacons apparently took that personally and decided to pound the Mustangs for it.

A good opening drive gave Wake Forest an early 7-0 lead, and after an interception in their own territory, they looked poised to jump on SMU early. A punt temporarily squashed those hopes, but after stopping SMU on downs, the floodgates opened.

Five straight touchdowns to end the first half made the score 42-0 in what felt like the blink of an eye. Everything went right for Wake Forest, and everything went wrong for SMU. After scoring to go up 35-0, the ensuing kickoff landed in no man's land and bounced backward right to the Demon Deacons. Even when they weren't trying, they were finding ways to destroy SMU.

Wake Forest's head coach delivered this line going into halftime:

And despite what he said, the Demon Deacons did seem to let off the gas a little in the second half, eventually settling for a 49-7 victory.

Wake Forest has now won its last six games by a combined score of 313-38. They have the second-best average scoring margin in the country and have proven that they need to be taken seriously.

With games against Georgia Tech and Duke remaining, they look poised to earn a rematch against Miami in the ACC Championship. We'll see what happens Tuesday night when the rankings come out, but it looks like they'll still need to win that rematch if they want a shot at the playoff.

Texas Tech

The Red Raiders seem to have found a new gear with quarterback Tommy Castellanos at the helm, as they beat Oklahoma State handily Saturday night in Stillwater.

Since losing to Cincinnati, they've beaten Arizona, West Virginia, and Oklahoma State, three teams with some pretty impressive offenses. Texas Tech dominated this game from start to finish, and despite a second-quarter push from the Cowboys, this one never really felt in doubt.

All week, people had been talking about how Texas Tech's defense wasn't the same as last year's, and how Drew Mestemaker and Oklahoma State were going to score at will. The defense must have been listening all week and finally had enough, because they held Mestemaker to his lowest statistical output since the season-opening loss to Tulsa. Similarly, Oklahoma State hadn't scored fewer points since that Tulsa game, and the 52 points they gave up were the most they've allowed all season.

While the stat sheet might not show Texas Tech completely overwhelming Oklahoma State, what happens on the field isn't always reflected in the numbers. From special teams to offense and defense, Texas Tech made a statement.

With two games remaining against in-state opponents Baylor and TCU, the Red Raiders look to be in the driver's seat to get back to Arlington and defend their title.

An 11-1 regular season would put Texas Tech in a great position heading into the Big 12 Championship. And even if they lose to Utah in the title game, I think they deserve another shot at the playoff. As long as they don't look like an FCS team against the Utes, there's no reason this team shouldn't be in the conversation.

Miami

The Hurricanes bounced back from their loss to Notre Dame with a solid win over the Duke Blue Devils. Despite Duke entering the game at 7-2, there was no reason to overlook Manny Diaz's squad. There was plenty of bad blood between these two teams, dating back to Diaz's history with Miami, as well as Cooper Barkate and Darian Mensah transferring to the Hurricanes in the offseason. Add in the fact that those two reportedly tried to convince Nate Sheppard to transfer as well, and you had a game that looked relatively benign on the surface but had some pretty strong undercurrents.

The back-and-forth nature of this game made for an entertaining first half, with Miami taking a 13-10 lead into the break. After a long pass to Javian Mallory, it looked like the Hurricanes were finally going to pull away for good. But Nate Sheppard answered the call with his second touchdown of the game. Unfortunately for Duke, it just wasn't enough. Mallory would add two more rushing touchdowns to put Miami out of reach and secure the win.

With games against Virginia Tech and Boston College remaining, Miami is in prime position to reach the ACC Championship, where the Hurricanes will look to win their first conference title since joining the ACC in 2004.


Game of the Week: Utah 40 Arizona 39

If you stayed up for this one, hopefully you had plenty of coffee ready for Sunday morning. No. 2 Utah traveled to Tucson to take on No. 23 Arizona in what turned into an absolute thriller, with seven lead changes and a finish that went down to the wire. The Utes escaped with a 40-39 victory, keeping their undefeated season alive and avoiding what would have been a massive playoff disaster.

Arizona came out swinging, jumping out to an early 14-3 lead and making it clear that they weren't going to be intimidated by the second-ranked team in the country. But Utah responded with 17 points in the second quarter, taking a 17-14 lead into halftime. The two teams traded punches throughout the second half, and every time it looked like one was ready to pull away, the other found a way to answer.

Daniel Bray was an absolute machine for the Utes, rushing for 197 yards and a touchdown. Devon Dampier added another 100 yards on the ground, along with two rushing touchdowns and two through the air. Arizona quarterback Noah Fifita wasn't exactly taking the afternoon off either, throwing for 356 yards and three touchdowns.

With just over three minutes remaining, Arizona took a 39-33 lead after a touchdown pass to Isaiah Mizell and a successful two-point conversion. It looked like the Wildcats were about to pull off the upset. But Dampier had other plans. On just the second play of Utah's next drive, he connected with Creed Whittemore for a 70-yard touchdown to take the lead right back with 2:35 remaining.

Arizona got one final opportunity, but a fourth-down pass fell incomplete, and Utah escaped with the win.

Once again, Utah found itself on the fortunate side of a controversial no-call involving an offensive lineman downfield. On a third-quarter touchdown pass to Byrd Ficklin, an offensive tackle was well beyond the line of scrimmage before the pass was thrown. The flag never came, and the touchdown stood.

This is becoming a pretty familiar conversation around Utah. Illegal man downfield has been a recurring point of frustration for opposing fans, and when a play like this happens in a one-point game, it's going to get noticed. You can argue whether the penalty would have changed the outcome of that particular drive, but it doesn't change the fact that it should have been called.

The Utes have certainly earned their 10-0 record, but these types of plays aren't going to make them many friends around the country.

Regardless, Utah survives and remains undefeated. With a 10-0 record and a clear path toward the Big 12 Championship, the Utes are firmly in control of their playoff destiny. Arizona gave them everything they could handle, but the difference between a playoff contender and an upset victim was one final drive by Devon Dampier.

And what a drive it was.


Player of the Week

Rasean Jones (Boise State): 11 REC, 230 YDS, 3 TD

Boise State hosted Oregon State and College GameDay this weekend in a matchup between what many considered the two best teams in the Pac-12. Oregon State would be without quarterback Braden Atkinson, but they still had their star freshman receiver, Jesse Legree, ready to go.

As it turned out, Boise State's freshman receiver Rasean Jones would outplay Legree at his own game. Jones sliced and diced the Beaver defense on his way to 239 total yards and three touchdowns, putting together one of the best performances of the weekend.

Boise State needed every bit of it, as the Broncos didn't put the game away until a nine-yard rush on their final possession moved the chains for a game-sealing first down. The 46-41 victory was anything but comfortable, but a win is a win.

Boise State now gets to host the Pac-12 Championship on the blue turf and is in prime position to claim the Group of Six playoff spot at the end of the season. With the conference title game on its home field, the Broncos have put themselves exactly where they want to be heading into the final stretch.


In Case You Missed it

MACtion Penalties

You ever seen a team get a 15 yard penalty for what was on the jumbotron...now you have.

13 Points in 2 seconds

It looked as if Western Kentucky was going to lose to Jacksonville State. They converted the second and 7 with just one second left on the clock, and added another score for good measure.

Bad Look for Kickers

USC's Caden Chittenden missed a 27 yard field goal in the fourth quarter that would have brought them within four. Indiana's on field entertainment made it sting worse when they brought out a fan in the ensuing timeout who drilled a 25 yard field goal right down the middle.

H-E-B Applications

Houston DC Austin Armstrong stated earlier this year that if he gave up 40 points this year he would be working at H-E-B, better start that application after Friday's loss to Colorado.

Fights

UNC lost a home game to Louisville, then started a fight, nice.

Punt of the Year?

We have another candidate for punt of the year, this time from Utah's Orion Phillips.

FAA Problems

Everyone knows what happened with the FAA Friday night, and it is amazing how almost every school was still able to get where they needed to go and play on Saturday. I say almost because Ole Miss decided to throw a fit and claim that they couldn't get to Norman Oklahoma with enough time to play a Saturday night game. They got SEC Commissioner Greg Sankey on their side and forced Oklahoma to move the game or forfeit. All that just to get beat.


The CFB Truth Podcast

I am happy to announce that I have joined a podcast! If the weekly newsletter and social media isn't enough for you, you can now tune in as we talk more about college football and The CFB Truth Index. Tune in Tuesdays and Fridays where ever you listen to your podcasts!


Will's Corner

Washington State 73, Colorado St 7

This was glorious.

With WSU's 130th-ranked offense going up against Colorado State's 138th-ranked defense, this was truly a stoppable force meets a movable object. And the Cougs cooked.

Washington State scored touchdowns on 10 of its 12 drives. The two that didn't end in touchdowns were a 35-second drive at the end of the first half, a drive where they went 60 yards before settling for a field goal. And the final drive of the game ended with Wazzu simply kneeling the clock out with a 73-7 lead inside the five yard line.

They converted 9 of 10 third downs, with the only failure coming on that final kneel-down. Their 535 rushing yards were the most in a single game in Washington State history, and they finished the afternoon with just one penalty.

Can we play Colorado State every week?

Kirby Vorhees and Maxwell Woods both finished with over 100 rushing yards, while Owen Eshelman added another 81. Nine of Wazzu's 10 touchdowns came on the ground, with Vorhees and Eshelman combining for seven of them. WSU hadn't had two 100-yard rushers in the same game since the 2005 season, and yesterday they nearly had three.

Before Saturday, Vorhees had 292 total yards and four touchdowns on the season. After this performance, he's now sitting at 489 yards and eight touchdowns. Not a bad afternoon for the running back.

This game was the focus of my Week 11 picks, and thanks to the Cougs' incredible performance, I went 5-0 for the second straight week.

I know this is just one game, and Colorado State isn't exactly the toughest opponent on the schedule, but the confidence this performance should give everyone on the roster heading into their final two games is huge. Just think, if Owen Eshelman had been starting from the beginning of the season, they might actually have made a bowl game.

BYU 28, Baylor 7

Yet again, another week of uninspiring football in the second half. Yes, BYU was up 21-0 at halftime, but we're getting to the point in the season where simply winning isn't enough for the Cougars anymore.

Texas Tech and Wake Forest both demolished their opponents this past week, while BYU continues to play with its food. Just 104 passing yards from Bear Bachmeier is once again concerning, and finishing with only 312 yards of total offense against a team like Baylor isn't going to cut it.

We've seen it countless times in the past: teams sitting comfortably in a playoff spot get dropped because their wins aren't convincing enough. BYU is in a prime position to become that team this year.

With Texas Tech winning Saturday night, it looks increasingly unlikely that BYU will be playing in Texas for the conference championship. The win over Notre Dame will do a lot of the heavy lifting for BYU's playoff resume, but convincing wins against Kansas and Cincinnati would go a long way toward making sure the Cougars aren't left sweating on Selection Sunday.

I understand there's a certain class in the way BYU wins games, but at some point, they need to stop being so nice. During Saturday night's Fox broadcast of Utah at Arizona, the announcers mentioned that Arizona had a real shot at beating BYU. They didn't. BYU should have won that game by 18 points, but instead, they did the nice thing and didn't score late. They did it again against Baylor, and they can't keep doing that.

Meanwhile, people are already making a case for Wake Forest this season, something that didn't happen for BYU last year when the Cougars were essentially doing the same thing. And I can already see the argument coming: Wake Forest is a legitimate playoff team, while BYU hasn't beaten anyone convincingly enough.

I don't want to see BYU sitting at home in December because the committee decided its wins weren't impressive enough. The Cougars have the resume, they have the talent, and they have the opportunity. But with just a few weeks left, it's time to stop playing down to the competition and start reminding everyone why this team belongs in the playoff.

Tennessee 22, Texas A&M 7

The Volunteers got some terrible news this week when RB2 Duane Morris was involved in a car accident and suffered a leg injury that will sideline him for the remainder of the season. Traveling to face a Texas A&M team that has underperformed all year was already something that gave just about every serious Vols fan anxiety heading into the weekend.

That anxiety certainly wasn't eased Saturday, as it seemed like Tennessee couldn't find the end zone. The Vols settled for field goals on all three of their first trips inside the red zone, leaving plenty of opportunities for a comfortable lead on the field.

Things got even more interesting when quarterback George MacIntyre had to leave the game with an apparent knee injury. Enter true freshman Faizon Brandon, who got his opportunity to lead the Vols to victory. He only needed one pass attempt to make his mark, finding the end zone for a touchdown that ultimately put the game away and gave Tennessee the 22-7 win.

Once again, Tennessee leaned on its defense and running game to get the job done. DeSean Bishop was excellent as always, while Javin Gordon stepped up and looks to have established himself as the No. 2 running back for the remainder of the season.

There are still plenty of questions heading into next week, though. It's unclear what the quarterback situation will look like against LSU, and receiver Mike Matthews also suffered an injury while fighting for extra yards on a play where the whistle seemed to come awfully late. His availability for next week is now in question as well.

The committee continues to prop up Alabama despite Tennessee knocking their teeth in earlier this season, but the Vols have an opportunity to make another statement. A win over LSU next weekend would go a long way toward solidifying Tennessee's spot in the playoff. A loss, however, would leave a whole lot more questions up in the air.


Survivor Pool Update

Everyone survived this week! With just two weeks of the regular season remaining, plus conference championship weekend, we are down to 13 people still standing.

Choose wisely as we're getting down to the wire. You'd hate to make it this far just to have your season come to an end because of one bad pick. Every week matters a little more now, and there isn't much room for error!


Games to Watch Week 12

  • Ohio St @ Nebraska – Nov 21, 12:00 PM ET (FOX) - Both have had terrible second half by their own metrics, but can Nebraska get a signature win over a depleted Buckeyes team?
  • LSU @ Tennessee– Nov 21, 3:30 PM ET (ABC) - LSU's season is done, can they end Tennessee's?
  • UCLA @ Michigan – Nov 21, 3:30 PM ET (CBS) - One of two unbeatens must traveled across the country to a hostile environment, doesn't matter how bad Michigan is, it's a tough place to play.
  • Utah @ TCU – Nov 21, 9:00 PM ET (FOX) - The other unbeaten must face their last real test of the season traveling to TCU.

Thank you for reading! It truly means a lot to me that you take the time to read this every week. If you enjoy the newsletter, please share it with your friends and family who love college football. Every new reader helps this thing grow, and I can't thank you enough! Don't forget to follow on socials!